Dear Abbas Ali, We are helpless. TCP files are compiled files of TDL( Which is not human Readable).It can be decompiled by the TDL developer who has got the same serial number. regards Jobimon
Mr. Abbas Ali and Mr. P Kumar, Please do not do this kind of things. To decode other developer's tcp file is unethical. What will you feel when other person will decode your tcp file and use it? Remember one thing that what we do to others, others can also do it to us. =========================================================== Dear Admin, You can remove my post from this forum if you think it is not right.
@Maulik Patel, I am collecting tcp file of other developers. As to learn about their views and possibilities. Please don't comment like this without knowing others intention.
What a logic.......................... What a dream......................... If your logic is right If I decompile and get source code of Widows or Mac I could know the views and possibilities of Mr. Bill Gate, Mr Steve Job Etc. ha ha ha Have you heard the term called copyright.
If want to learn, here it is worlds best site for tdl learning. for collecting tcp, go to tallyshop from www.tallysolutions.com http://www.tallysolutions.com/tallyweb/modules/sd/docmgmt/CMktPlaceHomepageWIC.php Better to create own, its give you soul satisfaction and proud. Again "Everything depends on your own thinking, what to do or not."
I am unable to understand the problem in it. Tally Solutions itself providing educational version tcp files for possibilities through tdl in tally, and those tcp's are not developed by me. If I am asking for some other tcp, it is the same as I have downloaded it from Tally Solution website or from somewhere else. I am wondered what is the problem to you people. If there is a possibility of decompilation, it is applicable to all tcp files. PK
No You are mistaken. First of all Tally is not giving TCP Files for education purpose. Tally gives TDL files which is human Readable. TCP files are compiled files generated from TDl file. Both TDL & TCP files work with tally. But the purpose of TCP file is to protect the source code from others so that you can get paid for your efforts. and no body else can steal the fruits of your efforts. Hence Tally does not allow decompilation of a tcp file into tdl file with another software. For Example, If you have a TDL Developer software under serial 000001 and you made tcp file from tdl. Then I can not decompile it with my software which is having serial number of 000002.This is done with an intention of intellectual property protection. Here in this thread Mr. Abbas ali wants to decompile TCP into TDL by violating intellectual property right of another person who made tcp.
Mr. Abbas ali wants to decompile TCP into TDL, how can you say that? He is asking for help regarding the problem in his existing tcp file. There is no question of decompilation. If anybody don't know about the decompilation. People like you will tell him regarding the possibilities in this field. Others will search for the same and get paid for others efforts if succeeded. There may be a reason that the original provider is not providing the help. There may be any no of reasons that Mr. Abbas ali wants help form this forum. Why are you so much worried.
Mr Abbas Ali. Your case can be analysed in two way Case First: You have asked the TDL developer to develop a TDL for exclusively for you and he developed it.Usually When we develop a tdl for a specific customer and for a specific customer we will give the source code for the future reference. You should have bought the source code also.It was your Fault.(I am not blaming you but It is truth).This case is a rare case. In that case only Tally Solutions can help you. But It is very difficult to convince them.Because There may be a valid reason from TDL developer for his act.( For E.g I may not take the calls of customer who is not prompt in payment or who is not a good customer ( I am not saying about you I gave example). Solution: Go to Tally Solutions They May help you.But Chances are very less Case Second: You have purchased a ready made TDL Solution from a 'developer A'. And you are going to 'developer B' for adding some more features then you need to develop a TCP/TDl for that features. If the TCP of Developer A is decompiled by 'Developer B' Then Developer B may sell the same for lesser price. Because the effort and cost to develop that TDL is Zero. Then how Developer A will Survive. Solution: Get a New TDl covering all your Requirements. One more thing I am using Tally developer Educational version. Since I am a TDL learner not a Professional Developer. I am an Accountant.
Please Read my First reply. It is stated what is possible and what is not possible. I am Quoting The same for your REading <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<Dear Abbas Ali, We are helpless.TCP files are compiled files of TDL( Which is not human Readable).It can be decompiled by the TDL developer who has got the same serial number.regardsJobimon >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> In his first query he has not explained his real problem.PLease see his reply also.
Mr. Abbas Ali and Mr. P Kumar Experts are not GOD so that they will know what is your intention and what are going in your mind. If you think that experts should not comment like this then both of you have to mention in detail. Unless and until you will write in detail , how will anybody know that you are not wrong. Mr. Abbas Ali has not told the issue of other developer and also not mentioned that he has purchased such kind of things so that all experts will surely think that he is requesting to help for decompile that tcp file. Mr. P Kumar, you have also not mentioned that you wants that tcp file for learning purpose, so by mentioning just your email id everybody will think that you are trying to decode that file. By your chat I came to know that you are asking tcp file for learning purpose. And its your kindness that you removed your emailid from this post on my request, I am thankful to your for that. But I would like to ask a question to you, How many of your developed tcp files you have given to other developers for learning purpose? If you are providing then its a wonderful thing but if you are not providing then i must say that you are one kind of selfish person. (Do not take it as a critic answer, its a truth) If you are not mentioning in detail then how could anybody know that what is your intention and what is your problem. If you are not mentioning total things that its your mistake not expert's mistake who is answering. You should mentioned whole things in your post. I am not finding your mistakes but giving you suggestions only to mention full details in your post. So PLEASE don't take it like a war between you and other developers.
